Skip to Menu Skip to Content Skip to Footer

Squib did eighth-disabled (Case number 74)

Attention: open in a new window. PDFPrint



The explosion of fireworks made the eighth-Ilnar Ahatova disabled view. The court found that the culprits in this case no.

From 3 to 24 October, 2005 Rights Center carries out the action "Take it, not lose, check it!" during which human rights defenders appealed resident Kazan Fania Ahatova. She asked for an investigation into a criminal case is not the Moscow district court of the city of Kazan on the owner of the kiosk "Alan" Naila Akhmetzyanova illegally sell "fireworks-rocket. Son Akhatova bought petard in this booth, in the explosion which he lost his vision right eye.
On this tragic day Ilnar mother sent her son to buy food at the local kiosk. On the way to the store, he met his friends. Seeing in the window "Alan" fireworks, the boys decided to make a little "holiday". But, forgetting about safety, Ilnar both bent down to the fireworks that the explosion of cutting his right eyeball. The mother of the victim, Fania Ahatova, received a medical examination by an ophthalmologist City Children's Polyclinic № 5 on the loss of the right eye.
Defending the rights of her son, she filed a lawsuit in the District Court of the city of Kazan to bring criminal proceedings against the owner of the kiosk "Alan" Naila Akhmetzyanova. But the court rejected it, finding that the crimes as such was not. According to the Committee on Consumer Protection Kazan kiosk owner in the list of companies authorized to trade fireworks, does not appear. They sold only fireworks exploding. Although, according to the seller Lyaysan Mustafino, rocket firecrackers "were on display in the kiosk. But in subsequent court hearings seller on his word refused, explaining that under the presence in the window "launch firecrackers, sparklers implied.
Repeated reviews of the Moscow district prosecutor in the case Akhatova did not yield positive results. Trying to restore the rights of their child, Fania Ahatova appealed to human rights defenders. After 7 months since the last court's refusal to institute criminal proceedings (November 10, 2005), 4 May 2006 a lawsuit was filed for compensation for harm caused to the health of her son, eleven-year $ 750 000. Ilnar Akhatov was treated at the Children's Republican Hospital, as well as in the Moscow Institute of Eye Diseases named after Helmholtz. A boy found the visually impaired. Doctors agree that the vision in the right eye is impossible to recover. Moreover, under threat is the sight of his left eye Ilnar. Despite this, the entrepreneur refused to pay. The court also accepted a claim, referring to the decision of Rospotrebnadzor RT, to dismiss the case for lack of offense in the sales kiosk owner.
As the lawyer of the city of Kazan Human Rights Center, Anis Amanullina: "Neither the Republican nor the federal legislation is no legislation that would regulate the sale of fireworks to children under the age of 16. The most striking thing is that on this basis, the owner of the kiosk could be subject to criminal and administrative responsibilities and whether the findings of sale. This means that a child can buy from the stalls at any volatile products and easy to injuring themselves.


Chronicle Antiproizvola

18.01.2005.
Fania Ahatova received honey. Ophthalmologic examination of the Children's City Polyclinic № 5 on the loss of the right eye of her son.
28.01.2005.
Moscow district court ruled the city of Kazan on refusal to initiate criminal proceedings against the owner of the kiosk "Alan" Naila Akhmetzyanova.
12.03.2005.
The second decree of the Moscow District Court, rejecting a claim Akhatova to institute criminal proceedings against the private entrepreneur Naili Akhmetzyanova.
07.05.2005.
Akhmetzyanova applied to the Moscow Regional Department of Consumer Protection to notice the lack of administrative violations in its area of activity.
14.05.2005.
Federal Service of the Republic of Tatarstan has concluded that the lack of offense the private entrepreneur Naili Akhmetzyanova.
27.05.2005.
The third decree of the Moscow District Court, rejecting a claim Akhatova to institute criminal proceedings against the private entrepreneur Naili Akhmetzyanova.
04.05.2006.
With defenders Fania Ahatova filed a claim for compensation for personal injury son the District Court for the kiosk owner "Alan" Akhmetzyanova Nail.
29.05.2006.
Moscow district court dismissed the claim for compensation for material and moral harm to his son Akhatova.


These are the facts gathered in the course of its Human Rights Center of Kazan public investigation. All statements and explanations given to citizens voluntarily. Not all of these facts can be confirmed by state authorities. Employees of the Human Rights Centre of Kazan confident that the facts indicate misconduct of agents of the state. Human Rights Centre reserves the right to seek an effective official investigation on them, including international institutions.

We will provide more detailed information, facts and evidence in each case. To do this, write us a letter.

Reports - Врачи