Skip to Menu Skip to Content Skip to Footer

Ministry of Finance refused to pay compensation in time ... (Case number 51)

Attention: open in a new window. PDFPrint

In May 2003, a resident of Naberezhnye Chelny Bulat Mukhametzyanov (name changed in favor of the victim) was beaten by unknown assailants in her apartment building.
During the interrogation, the man suggested that the organizer of the attack is the head of a rival firm. A few days later a preliminary criminal investigation into the attack on Bulat has been suspended in connection with an unidentified person who committed the crime.

World Court declared Mukhametzyanova guilty to part 3, st.129 Criminal Code (slander) and sentenced him to imprisonment for a term of 6 months suspended for 6 months.
The victim managed to appeal to the Supreme Court of Tatarstan, which overturned earlier rulings by decree of the judges and municipal court of Naberezhnye Chelny and suspended criminal proceedings against Mukhametzyanova for its failure to act constitutes a crime.
A year later, Bulat appealed to the Human Rights Centre of Kazan during the campaign "Rehabilitation", to which any citizen could become a republic, a justifiable whole or in part, and against whom criminal proceedings were discontinued.
The lawyers have helped the organization achieve Mukhametzyanova ruling Magistrate Court by the Ministry of Finance of the Russian Federation was obliged to pay the affected 7000 rubles as compensation for property damage.
In addition, specialists Kazan Human Rights Center were a claim for compensation for moral damage, the amount of which was eventually reduced the city of Naberezhnye Chelny in court 15 times and amounted to 10 000 rubles.
But even this money Bulat Mukhametzyanov could not get in time, as the city of Naberezhnye Chelny court for an unknown reason, has sent a writ of execution is not in the Treasury, and the bailiff service Novo Savinovskogo area of the city of Kazan.
Further implementing documents in transit through the Department of Federal Service of Court Bailiffs of Tatarstan headed to the Moscow administration bailiffs.
As a result, the writ of execution was lost. Mukhametzyanova took time to get a duplicate. In January this year, the victim himself sent a writ of execution in the Ministry of Finance.
According to the legislation, the federal agency must within three months to transfer money to the victim, but this has not been. Kazan defenders prepared a statement in the Tver court of Moscow's recognition of Treasury's actions illegal.
Russian Finance Ministry did not wait for the trial and paid compensation to the victims.

Chronicle Antiproizvola

29.09.2003 - Naberezhnye Chelny Public Prosecutor's Office filed against Raisa Sahapova criminal case on the grounds of a crime under the Criminal Code, part 3 of st.129 - libel, coupled with the accusation of committing a grave or especially grave crime.
10.10.2003 - Naberezhnye Chelny Public Prosecutor's Office ordered the case to connect the criminal investigation of a crime under part 1 of article. 165 of the Criminal Code (causing damage to property by deception or abuse of trust) with the criminal case brought against Sahapova AD for the crime provided st.129 Part 3 of the Criminal Code. 29.10.2003 - E. Gusynin investigator decided to discontinue the criminal case for lack of evidence.
5.11.2003 - Deputy Attorney Naberezhnye Chelny Khairyllin IA ordered the cancellation of the termination of criminal proceedings. The criminal case was reopened.
26.03.2004 - Magistrate court plot number 20 on Mr. Naberezhnye Chelny Tatarstan V. Platonov acknowledged Raisa Sahapova guilty of an offense under st.129 Part 3 of the Criminal Code and sentenced to imprisonment for a term of 6 months suspended with probation for 6 months.
6.05.2004 - Judge Naberezhnochelninskogo Federal City Court RT Nabiev IG ordered to leave the sentence the magistrate, without changes, and the appeal was dismissed.
28.05.2004 - Judicial Collegium for Criminal Cases of the Supreme Court of Tajikistan has made cassation definition, under which the sentence the magistrate court plot number 20 on the city of Naberezhnye Chelny on March 26, 2004 and the city court ruling Naberezhnochelninskogo RT from May 6, 2004 in respect of Sahapova AD were abolished, the criminal proceedings in the case dismissed for lack of corpus delicti.
9.11.2005 - Naberezhnye Chelny City Court of RT recovered from the treasury of Russia in favor of Rice Sahapova 10 000 rubles as compensation for moral harm.
27.08.2007 - Rais Sahapov lawyer said that the amount of 10 000 rubles came to his bank account.

These are the facts gathered in the course of its Human Rights Center of Kazan public investigation. All statements and explanations given to citizens voluntarily. Not all of these facts can be confirmed by state authorities. Employees of the Human Rights Centre of Kazan confident that the facts indicate misconduct of agents of the state. Human Rights Centre reserves the right to seek an effective official investigation on them, including international institutions.

We will provide more detailed information, facts and evidence in each case. To do this, write us a letter.

Reports - Деньги