Skip to Menu Skip to Content Skip to Footer

Seven at one blow! (Case number 13)

Attention: open in a new window. PDFPrint

Without explaining police officer opened fire on the village boys. The bullet pierced right through one teenager and went into the back of another.


The audit found that on Oct. 4, 2003 two teenage citizens Shamsutdinov Rishat Kamilevich and Hayrutdinov ILMIR Idrisovich approximately 11 hours and 30 minutes of riding on a motorcycle in the village bazaar Mottaki Ion Alkeevskogo region of the Republic of Tatarstan. St. School began their chase vehicle KAMAZ. They stopped. After that came out of the truck KAMAZ police officer in uniform and went in the direction of teenagers. But he made no gesture and said nothing. Hayrutdinov Shamsutdinov and drove on. Passing on the street. Dzerzhinsk, they noticed a car VAZ 2110, which overtook them. When a car and a motorcycle came up, the "tens" open the front right window of about 10 centimeters, and Shamsutdinov saw the face of a stranger to him a man who shouted something to him. Shamsutdinov not hear the words and did not stop. He added speed and overtook cars, then the man sitting in the "top ten" shot three times in the direction of juveniles with a gun. One bullet hit the body sitting behind Khairutdinova, and punched him right through, went back Shamsutdinova. The second bullet hit the motorcycle helmet Shamsutdinova without causing harm to a teenager. The third bullet hit the minors. Warning shots was not.
Shamsutdinov was able to get away from pursuers and arrived at the river, where he found that he and Khairutdinova have bullet wounds. Shamsutdinov invited to go to the hospital, but Hayrutdinov feared that the gunmen would come and go. They decided to go home. Arriving there, they told their parents about the incident, which caused them to an ambulance. Teens taken to hospital where they received medical assistance.
The audit found that of the car VAZ 2110 shooting officer police department Alkeevskogo F.
Given that adolescents were not committed any wrongful acts, in accordance with Article 15 of the Federal Law "On militia" giving rise to the standard-issue firearms, one can conclude that the weapons have been used inappropriately Fatyhovym.

In the course of the audit were interviewed:
- Shamsutdinova AF
- Shamsutdinov RK,
- Hayrutdinov IM
We studied the medical records, intermingled in the newspaper "Evening Kazan» № 166 from 15.10.2003 "shooting to kill on adolescents' characteristics were obtained from school and Shamsutdinova Khairutdinova, found that the prosecutor's office Alkeevskogo District of Tatarstan opened a criminal case against F.
Despite the fact that the use of weapons, was not the cause of death, the actions of a police officer can be described as a violation of the right to life, because death was caused by circumstances beyond the security officer Fatyhova circumstances, and his actions could well lead to the unintentional loss of life suffered because was made three shots on target engagement.

Based on the foregoing, I think that in this case, the actions of the police department Alkeevskogo a perceived violation of Art. 2 (right to life) of the European Convention on Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms. (Decision of the European Court of Human Rights on June 27, 2000 Ilham v. Turkey). In addition, the actions of FA discernible signs of a crime under Article 286 part 3, paragraph "b" of the Criminal Code.
For a thorough public investigation must have a cause of human rights violations and take it to the production of the city of Kazan Human Rights Center

Specialist investigations
Human Rights Centre of Kazan

Chronicle Antiproizvola

December 18
Judge Alkeevskogo district court was sentenced to recognize Fatyhova RG guilty of abuse of office ("b" part 3 of art. 286 of the Criminal Code) and imposing a sentence - 3 years' imprisonment (suspended), with disqualification to hold office security officer's Economic Crimes Alkeevskogo police department for three years.

These are the facts gathered in the course of its Human Rights Center of Kazan public investigation. All statements and explanations given to citizens voluntarily. Not all of these facts can be confirmed by state authorities. Employees of the Human Rights Centre of Kazan confident that the facts indicate misconduct of agents of the state. Human Rights Centre reserves the right to seek an effective official investigation on them, including international institutions.

We will provide more detailed information, facts and evidence in each case. To do this, write us a letter.

Reports - Правоохранители